You can start with the HEIMORIOTO holster if you own more than one pistol, since the maker says it fits sizes from subcompact to full-size. That means one holster can cover more than one gun in your safe.
The maker describes the holster as waterproof and built from 1000D nylon, and it can be worn inside or outside the waistband. For daily carry, that means it handles rain and sweat better than a basic fabric holster, and you can pick the carry position that suits your clothes. The maker also advises against attaching a laser sight or flashlight to the pistol while it is in this holster.
The rest of this article covers the other four picks, grouped by who each one suits, followed by a quick guide to matching a holster to your pistol.
Key takeaways
It is built from waterproof 1000D nylon and carries inside or outside the waistband.
Do not use it with a laser sight or flashlight attached.
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
How we picked: from products sold on Amazon for this need, compared by what their makers state and what buyers report in their reviews.
The Picks at a Glance
Product | Best for | Size | Material | Material type | Buyer rating | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
HEIMORIOTO Holster | owners of several pistol sizes | One Size Fits Most | Nylon | Nylon | 4.4 of 5 (1,547 reviews) | |
DMAIP Universal Holster | left-handed carriers | Large | Nylon | Nylon | 4.3 of 5 (2,714 reviews) | |
U UOOGEAR OWB Holster | full-size and compact pistols | Right | Polymer | Polymer | 4.3 of 5 (797 reviews) | |
iMXPW Leather Shoulder Holster | under-shirt carry | Adjustable | Faux Leather | Faux Leather | 4.3 of 5 (571 reviews) | |
GHFY Drop Leg Holster | right-handed thigh carry | One | Nylon | Nylon | 4.3 of 5 (7,464 reviews) |
Buyer ratings as shown on Amazon on October 13, 2026; they change.
HEIMORIOTO Holster: Best for owners of several pistol sizes
HEIMORIOTO’s Gun Holster for Men and Women is the first pick for owners of several pistol sizes. The maker says it was designed for everything from a subcompact handgun to a full-size pistol, so one holster can cover more than one gun you own.
The maker says it fits Glock 17, 19, 26 and 43x among many other models. If you carry a small Glock on some days and a larger pistol on others, you do not need a separate holster for each. It is also listed for 9mm, .380 and .45 ACP pistols more broadly.
The holster is made of waterproof, sturdy 1000D nylon. That helps it hold up when you carry in wet weather or sweat. The clip can be moved for right- or left-hand carry, and it fastens to a belt about 2 inches wide. Check that your belt is that width before you buy. (Stated fact: the clip fastens to a 2 inch wide belt.)
Pros
The maker lists it for a wide range of 9mm, .380 and .45 ACP pistols.
Buyers say it fits their pistol well.
Buyers say it is comfortable to wear.
Cons
The maker advises against using lasers or flashlights with it.
Buyers say the holster slides off the belt clip and belt.
Buyers say it is too small for some pistols.
If you carry one pistol and want a holster built only for that gun, look at the other picks below.
DMAIP Universal Holster: Best for left-handed carriers
The DMAIP Universal Holster is the pick for left-handed carriers, because the maker says it supports both right- and left-handed use. It works for inside-the-waistband (IWB) and outside-the-waistband (OWB) carry, so you can choose the position that suits your clothes. You may also find this useful: Best Appendix Carry Holsters: 5 Picks and How to Choose.
The holster has a reinforced metal clip that the maker says keeps it firmly in place during movement, drawing and daily carry. For you, that means less shifting when you sit, bend or reach, and a holster that stays where you set it. The body is made of 1000D nylon with reinforced stitching, which the maker describes as built for long-lasting durability. That fabric holds up to daily wear better than thin material would.
Pros
Works for left-handed and right-handed carriers, IWB or OWB.
The metal clip keeps it from shifting during movement and drawing.
Built for compact and subcompact models such as the Glock 19, Glock 26 and M&P Shield.
Cons
It is designed for compact and subcompact pistols, so a full-size frame is outside its stated fit.
If you carry a full-size pistol, look at another pick, such as the Universal OWB Holster, which is made for full-size and compact pistols.
U UOOGEAR OWB Holster: Best for full-size and compact pistols
The U UOOGEAR Universal OWB Holster is the pick for outside-the-waistband carriers with a full-size or compact pistol, such as a Glock 17 or a Sig P320. The maker states it fits more than 100 pistols, which covers most common duty and carry models.
The maker states it has an index finger release and an adjustable cant. The release lets you press a finger against the holster’s release point as you draw, which helps keep the trigger clear of the holster during the draw. The cant lets you tilt the gun at the hip, so you can find the angle that feels natural for your draw.
The maker states it is built from polymer and has a paddle that fits belts 1.5 to 2.0 inches wide. A paddle slides between the belt and your pants, so you can take the holster off without unthreading your belt. The maker also states the paddle rotates 360 degrees and comes with an Allen key for adjustments.
Pros
Works for right- and left-handed draws.
Adjustable cant changes the angle of the gun at the hip.
Buyers say the paddle makes it quick to put on and take off.
Cons
The maker states it is engineered for pistols with barrels around 4.7 inches, so it is not compatible with micro-compact pistols.
If you carry a micro-compact or a pistol with a light or laser attached, look at another pick instead.
iMXPW Leather Shoulder Holster: Best for under-shirt carry
The iMXPW Leather Shoulder Holster is the pick for under-shirt carry. It suits buyers who want the pistol on the shoulder, hidden under a shirt, with spare magazines close at hand. The maker states it is designed to be worn covertly under your shirt.
The maker lists fit with Glock 17, 19 and 23, Sig P220 and P226, and full-size 1911 pistols. If you carry one of those, you have a short, specific list to match your gun against before you buy.
The holster has 2 pockets for magazines. A spare magazine stays under your shirt instead of in a pants pocket. The shoulder strap adjusts from 13 inches to 23 inches, and a 4-point pivoting harness changes the angle of the strap. In daily use, that lets you set the fit to your build instead of wearing one fixed length.
The maker describes it as made of durable double-stitched leather.
Pros
Two magazine pockets keep spares within reach.
Buyers say the straps adjust easily to fit different body types.
Buyers say it is comfortable to wear, even for long stretches.
Buyers say it is well made and sturdy.
Cons
Buyers repeat that it does not stay in place when they move.
Buyers say the material feels cheap.
The shoulder holster is for right-handed users, so left-handed carriers need another model.
Left-handed carriers should look at the Universal Gun Holster for Men & Women instead.
GHFY Drop Leg Holster: Best for right-handed thigh carry
The GHFY Drop Leg Holster is the pick for right-handed carriers who want a thigh holster that adjusts to different leg sizes. Its adjustable straps and right-hand orientation are what put it on this list.
The maker states this is a fully adjustable open leg holster built for different thigh sizes. If your leg size changes with the season, say from thin pants in summer to heavier ones in winter, you can resize the holster instead of buying a new one.
The maker also says it has a hook-and-loop closure, can attach to your belt, and uses dual thigh straps with nonslip backing to keep the gun against your leg. The belt option gives you a second point of support, so the holster does not rely on the thigh straps alone when you walk or climb.
Pros
Adjustable open leg design for different thigh sizes
Made for men and women, so the same holster works for either
Buyers say it takes full-sized handguns with ease
Cons
Usually made for the right hand and right thigh, so left-handed carriers need another model
Buyers report that it feels flimsy and not sturdy
Buyers report that the Velcro straps come loose
If you carry left-handed, look at the Universal Gun Holster for Men & Women instead.
How do you choose the right holster for your pistol and carry style?
Start with where you will carry, then match the holster to your exact pistol and your dominant hand. Those three choices narrow the field more than any brand name.
Inside the waistband (IWB) holsters sit between your belt and your body, so the gun stays hidden. Outside the waistband (OWB) holsters sit on the outside of your belt, so the gun is easier to reach and draw. Some makers cover both positions with one holster. DMAIP, for example, lists both IWB and OWB carry.
Fit depends on the pistol’s frame size and barrel length, so the same holster can feel loose on one gun and tight on another. U UOOGEAR states that its holster is engineered for handguns with barrels around 4.7 inches, and that it is not compatible with micro-compact pistols. If your pistol is a smaller model, that limit matters more than any feature on the box. Buyers also report that one universal holster is too small for some pistols.
Your dominant hand decides which side the holster must draw from. The iMXPW shoulder holster is made for right-handed users, and the GHFY drop leg holster is usually sold for a right hand and right thigh. If you are left-handed, look for a holster that works on both sides, such as DMAIP’s model.
Kydex holsters are light, and Vedder Holsters describes its Kydex holsters as ultralight [1]. Less weight on your belt makes all-day carry easier. The same maker also calls its Kydex holsters comfortable and easy to conceal [1].
Which choice should you make first?
Start with where you will carry the gun, because that decides which type of holster you need before you compare models. Inside-the-waistband (IWB) holsters sit inside your pants and stay hidden, while outside-the-waistband (OWB) holsters are easier to reach. Once you know that, the choice narrows fast.
If you own more than one pistol size, HEIMORIOTO is the first pick. The maker says it fits sizes from subcompact to full-size, so one holster can cover a small carry gun and a larger one at home. That saves you from buying a separate holster for each frame.
One holster for several guns is only useful if it holds each of them well, so try the fit with your own pistol before you carry it daily. Then pick the carry position and holster type that suits your clothes and daily routine. Your next step is to look at the models that match your carry position and your dominant hand.